Buying Vinyl; photo by New Africa

The Nostalgia Economy: Why Is America So Obsessed With the Past?


My 16-year-old’s girlfriend came for dinner on Monday night, so I made beef stew. Not anything fancy: beef (tossed in seasoned flour and browned), sliced carrots, onions, and celery, a can of stewed tomatoes, and plenty of broth, served over egg noodles. It’s the same recipe my mom used when I was a kid in the 1970s. The kids each ate two bowls, and my teen’s been taking leftovers to lunch all week in his vintage (circa 1980s) thermos.

That stew’s one example of something happening all over the country (world?) right now. Jell-O salad is having a moment. So is tomato aspic, somehow. (Yes, that savory tomato gelatin dish, and yes, people — including one of my neighbors — are making it intentionally). Watergate salad is having another moment, as are deviled eggs, seven-layer salad, and cheese balls. They’re not elegant, but these comfort foods have something even better than taste — they have a memory attached.

TikTok’s #GrandmasRecipes and #RetroCooking tags are doing for worn, food-stained cookbooks what thrifting flips did for Levi’s and Berks. We’re remembering and recreating the food our parents and grandparents made, and in my case, anyway, teaching our kids to do the same. Yup, my teen wants to try making a chicken stew recipe (also from the early 1980s) himself the next time his girlfriend comes to dinner.

Read: Move Over, 20-Somethings. Grandma Is Kicking Your Butt on TikTok

Discover: Ryan Reynolds Turns 50. Welcome to the Club, Deadpool

You spin me round

It’s the same tune with vinyl. I spent days in my room as a teen listening to my parents’ 33s and 45s, flipping to the B-side because my player’s arm didn’t have the auto-flip option. I left for college and learned about a “new-fangled” music option: CDs. They took up far less room, and vinyl began to feel clunky by comparison. All that surface static. All that flipping.

Then a couple of years ago, I heard that familiar scratchy crackle drifting from a store, and it yanked me back to age 11, dancing to Duran Duran’s Rio in my parents’ living room. We don’t have room for a record player right now, but I still want one. The nostalgia is strong!

And I’m not just basking in sentimentality, either. Vinyl has outsold CDs in the U.S. every year since 2022. In 2025, U.S. vinyl sales cracked $1 billion. Who knew?!

Everything old is comfortable again

Retro tech and decor are creeping back into people’s homes, too. My son has a lava lamp in his bedroom. I seriously contemplated a 1950s-style stove when I updated my kitchen two years ago. A friend has a little boxy TV on her countertop, harkening back to the 1990s.

As much as my contemporaries and I love our tech, it’s nice to get a break from smart bulbs, smartphones, Wi-Fi-connected refrigerators, and all the technical gadgets (and decor) that do 15 things you didn’t ask for. Every time I look at my macrame plant hanger and run my feet through the burnt orange shag rug warming my attic floor, I smile.

A 20-year rerun

Even fashion has entered the nostalgia game. Museum curator James Laver noticed back in the 1930s that trends typically resurface about 20 years after their first appearance. The journey goes from embarrassing to charming, around the time that the generation that lived through it the first time hits its prime spending years.

The somewhat cheeky Laver’s Law holds up: Gen Z is leaning into Y2K’s butterfly clips, low-rise jeans, baby tees, and velour tracksuits that millennials winced at a decade ago. My teen’s current uniform? Baggy, distressed jeans and oversized hoodies. And I may have squealed (and subsequently freed) a Burberry check-patterned honest-to-goodness cashmere scarf from my mom’s closet as we sorted its contents recently.

The science of nostalgia

Psychologists Constantine Sedikides, Tim Wildschut, and Clay Routledge — all credited with building the modern science of nostalgia in the mid-2000s — found that we tend to reach for nostalgia when we’re stressed, lonely, or uncertain about what’s coming next.

I feel targeted here. My friends have told me I need to watch dozens of new TV shows, but my go-to show when I have time? Star Trek: The Next Generation, another 1980s relic. Choosing the familiar isn’t an escape hatch so much as a reset button, reminding us who we are and who’s stood by us, which helps us feel steady when everything around us feels unstable.

And the way the 1970s and 1980s are slamming back into our movie screens and TV sets seems endless. The Karate Kid movies from the 1980s brought us the Cobra Kai streaming series – if you loved The Karate Kid how could you not at least give the recent update a look to see what Daniel LaRusso and Johnny Lawrence were up to decades later?  Fifty years after the classic Rocky came out, we are getting I Play Rocky later this month.  Not exactly a sequel, but you get the idea. Did we really need a sequel to the classic Spinal Tap? Probably not, but we got it anyway in 2025.

Speaking of music, some bands that made it big with MTV are hitting the road again to see if their classics still hold up live. (Spoiler alert: Some do and some don’t.)

Psychologist Krystine Batcho, who’s studied nostalgia since the 1990s, has connected today’s wave to cost-of-living stress. When the present feels expensive and uncertain, the past starts to look much more affordable.

Nostalgia has an age, too

Ask a room full of people over 50 what nostalgia feels like, and you’ll get something less curated than a trend piece but more specific than a survey. I polled my friends and family to ask about what makes them nostalgic.

Dad (age 99) appreciates dinner table conversations without screens competing for attention. Mom (age 85) still flips on the radio to listen to her beloved Phillies because she loves closing her eyes and imagining the gameplay. My bestie (age 56) recently bought a 3-speed bicycle with a handlebar basket that reminded her of the bike she rode as a kid. Another friend (age 62) recently introduced her grandchildren to Looney Tunes.

My great-aunt (age 106) and I were talking at our annual family reunion this past summer. She said that nostalgia is being reminded of people you’ve lost and wishing you could still call them. Some of what we remember fondly was legitimately better. Some was more inconvenient in a way that’s hard to recreate on purpose (waiting a week to see if your photos turned out or if you accidentally exposed the film removing from your camera, taping a song off the radio and living with the DJ talking over the last ten seconds forever after).

The generation that lived through it originally isn’t wrong to miss it. The generation that skipped it isn’t wrong to feel relieved, either.

Does nostalgia dampen new creation?

Not everyone thinks nostalgia is good. Some argue that we’ve stopped making new culture in favor of recycling the old stuff on a loop. From where I sit, I disagree. My home office is within earshot of my son’s bedroom.

He’s 16, and the music blasting into the hallway isn’t technically 70s soul and funk. It’s Bruno Mars, Greta Van Fleet, Laufey, Natalie Jinju, Daniel Caesar, and AJR (among others) — artists who grew up on the same influences I did and who are sharing them (with their own unique spin) with a new generation.

I also hear a lot of the Jackson 5. And Norah Jones, Radiohead, Pink Floyd, and Stevie Wonder. My son might not have “discovered” these influences if it weren’t for today’s musicians.

And maybe that’s the story behind this nostalgia economy. We’re not stuck in the past — but the past provides warmth and comfort when the present feels unsettled. And when you can bring someone along, it’s even better.


More from Nifty50+