The 5 Safest and 5 Most Dangerous States for Senior Drivers
You’ve probably heard news stories of senior drivers who have suffered spectacular car crashes, often involving the fatality of the driver, passengers, or others. The stories often hit close to home as we think of our loved ones on the road who could be in danger. They also stand out in our minds because there are fewer licensed drivers ages 70+, yet, per mile traveled, fatal crash rates increase substantially amongst older drivers, according to data from the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS). Fatal crashes are highest amongst drivers aged 85 and up.
Read: Essential Car Prep for Handling Emergencies
Discover: Avoiding Travel Scams: A Guide for Older Adults
The rise in fatal motor vehicle crashes has been a persistent trend since 1975, with deaths of people 70+ rising by 50% between 1975 and 2024 (the most recent year for which data is available).
There’s good news, though.
With more drivers on the road today, the rate of fatalities per capita amongst the 70+ crowd has actually dropped by 47%. New safety features in cars, safer roads, more stoplights, and even stricter drunk driving laws have made the roads safer for all ages.
The CR Legal Team recently analyzed crash data to find the least and most dangerous states for senior drivers based on fatal crashes per 100,000 licensed drivers ages 65 and up. Surprisingly, more senior drivers did not necessarily translate into more fatal accidents.
We break down the data below.
Which are the states deemed most deadly to senior drivers?
Most Dangerous States for Senior Drivers
Mississippi
Mississippi tops the list with 20.39 deaths per 100,000 senior drivers, or 109 total deaths in 2024. Alarmingly, there was a 45.9% increase between 2020 and 2024. Across the US, however, 2020 death rates may skew lower than average because of the pandemic-related lockdowns that led to fewer cars on the road.
South Dakota
South Dakota, with a population of less than 1 million people, has a relatively high death for senior drivers in car crashes, with a rate of 18.98 in 2024. However, this figure represents 33 deaths per year, a fairly small number compared to more populated states.
Historically, according to research from the South Dakota Department of Transportation, the state has struggled with a high rate of fatal crashes across all demographics, often attributed to drunk driving, distracted driving, and speeding.
Wyoming
South Dakota’s neighbor Wyoming is also more dangerous for senior drivers, with a 2024 fatality rate of 18.46 per 100,000 senior drivers. Again, the total number is relatively low, at 21 deaths in 2024. There’s also some good news for Wyoming senior drivers; the fatal crash rate dropped by 5.6% between 2020 and 2024.
Oklahoma
Oklahoma ranks fourth on the list of most dangerous states for senior drivers, with 17.34 fatalities per 100,000 drivers 65+. The fatal crash rate has jumped by 34.7% since 2020, leading to a total of 103 crashes in 2024.
Missouri
Missouri rounds out the top five most dangerous states for senior drivers, with a total of 170 deaths, or a 16.53 fatal crash rate. Seniors aren’t the only ones in danger on the road in the Midwest state. A report from the Advocates for Highway and Auto Safety ranked Missouri as the worst state for traffic safety laws, according to a report from Fox4KC.com.
Safest States for Senior Drivers
Rhode Island
With a fatality rate of just 2.11 per 100,000 senior drivers, or four deaths in 2024, Rhode Island tops the list of safest states for senior drivers. Rhode Island also scored an 8 from the Advocates for Highway and Auto Safety, earning high marks for traffic laws that encourage safer roads.
Hawaii
Retiree-friendly Hawaii ranks second on the list of safest states for senior drivers, with only 8 fatalities in 2024 and a fatal crash rate of 3.28.
Vermont
Vermont’s safety record for seniors shows that it’s not the number of older drivers on the road that makes a difference. Nearly one-third (29.2%) of Vermont drivers are seniors – the second highest percentage in the country – yet Vermont holds third place on our list of safest states for senior drivers.
New York
With 4.70 fatal crashes per 100,000 licensed seniors, New York lands fourth on the list. Its high population brings that death toll up to a relatively high 139. Public transportation in major metro areas may encourage seniors to drive less (even if they have licenses), leading to fewer crashes. New York State transportation laws also favor safer roads; the state scored 8 points from Advocates for Highway and Auto Safety.
Washington DC
Washington DC scored nine points from the advocacy organization and also landed fifth on the list of safest states for senior drivers. It had a fatal crash rate of 4.74 and just three senior deaths in 2024. Like New York, DC has an extensive public transportation system and excellent traffic safety laws.
What This Means for Safer Roads for Seniors
CR Legal Team researchers noted in the report that state level factors, not population size, contribute to riskier roads. Road design, speed limits, licensing checks for seniors and even vehicle safety standards play into safer roads for every demographic.
How Drivers Can Help Keep Roads Safe
Senior drivers can play a role in safer roads, too. Here are some tips to consider:
Take a defensive driving course: A refresher course can remind you of good habits. Plus, you may get insurance discounts for completing a course, which you can take online.
Don’t drive: If you feel tired or, obviously, if you’re intoxicated or impaired, leave the driving to someone else.
Watch how prescription meds affect you: If you’re taking prescription medication, take time to see how your body reacts to it before you get on the road; some medications can make you drowsy or cause lightheadedness.
Know when to stop: Giving up your license can feel like surrendering a level of freedom. But if you have difficulty seeing or notice your response time has slowed significantly, it’s time to look into other transportation options.
